I saw this on Etsy and thought it might spark discussion.

Which is Better?

Pearl Jam

OR

Nirvana

Your opinions welcome in the comments.

All viewpoints are welcome. Please keep your comments profanity free. Do not flame others. HTML links will not work. Please just post any links as is in your comment.

You must answer the captcha question in order for your comment to post. If you don't know the answer, let me know. I may or may not give it to you.

I reserve the right to delete and/or edit objectionable comments. Be nice and have fun!




1. No contest, Pearl Jam.

   Not sure I have a convincing reason for that though, just basic gut reaction. Perhaps it’s because Eddie can actually, you know, sing. Which is something Kurt never managed.

   Posted by beth  on  04/09/08  at  07:17 AM

2. NIRVANA!

   Though, Pearl Jam was AWESOME (and, their newest album is incredible, fyi)

   Posted by  on  04/09/08  at  08:38 AM

3. Hmmm, only two votes so far? Somehow I expected more.

   I lean to Nirvana, but agree that Eddie is a better singer than was Kurt.

   Posted by jen  on  04/09/08  at  01:07 PM

4. Sirius Radio’s grunge station had me in heaven a few days ago:

   6 songs in a row:
   2 - Pearl Jam
   2 - Nirvana
   2 - Stone Temple Pilots

   All was good for roughly 15 minutes :)

   Posted by  on  04/09/08  at  02:54 PM

5. I’d vote, but honestly?  I couldn’t tell you what either one sounds like.  I lived in a cave in the 90s.

   Posted by Gwynne  on  04/09/08  at  03:40 PM

6. PJ.

   They defined my college years (up to becoming a Christian anyway).

   Nirvana was the opening act in the soundtrack of my life over that same time frame. Whenever either comes up on iTunes, I’ll always listen to PJ, and try to convince my son this was a definitive sound, but often hit “next” when it comes to Nirvana.

   Posted by Bryan  on  04/10/08  at  10:27 AM

7. Stone Temple Pilots beats both, Nirvana comes in second.

   I’m a Boomer, so my vote probably doesn’t count

   Posted by Alan K. Henderson  on  04/12/08  at  11:52 PM

<< Back to main